&Juliet, Sheffield Lyceum Theatre, May 2025

Last night we got our ‘Bard on and headed to Sheffield’s Lyceum Theatre for &Juliet. We caught the production in Leeds last year, but thought we’d see it (Baby) One More Time…

The production follows other historical happenings such as SIX and Hamilton, and breathes new life and ideas into Shakespeare. Don’t expect the literary tale as written, instead the story explores what would happen if Juliet didn’t kill herself. Here, she starts a new life in Paris without needing a Romeo to call her own. Expect girl power, modern language and themes, and a banging soundtrack of 90’s favourites. It’s a megamix of hits from Britney and Bon Jovi, to Kelly Clarkson, Katy Perry and even The Backstreet Boys.

Jay McGuinnes fills the shoes of Shakespeare himself. Likeable and engaging, and suitably smug in reminding the audience which famous phrases he wrote. His relationship with Anne Hathaway is bittersweet, and the pair work well together.

This is our second time seeing Gerardine Sacladan (Juliet) and Lara Denning (Anne), and we can say unreservedly that they are two of the best musical theatre performers we’ve seen in any show. Powerhouse vocals with perfection in every note, and engaging performances throughout. Denning’s heartfelt That’s The Way It is is a highlight, and Sacladan manages to deliver a passionate performance even when sat on the floor or flying through the air. Incredible.

We’d also seen Jordan Broatch’s May and Kylie Cox’ Francois before, and both absolutely excel in the roles. Broatch delivers I’m Not a Girl so movingly, and has an endearing quality and quiet sincerity. Cox’s nerdy Francois wrestles with his new feelings towards May, but also wrings comedy out of the role with daft piano playing and cringe-inducing social awkwardness.

More comedy comes from Nurse Angelique (Sandra Marvin) who tries to keep Juliet on the straight and narrow, but ultimately gives up and goes wayward herself. Marvin’s voice is rich and soulful, and she swoons for old love interest Lance, played by understudy Michael Nelson. Nelson brings some French swagger to the role, but plays it more seriously than Raj Singh we’ve previously seen. Singh played the part more tongue-in-cheek, but both found the funnies in the dance numbers.

But what of Romeo, dear Romeo? Benjamin Jackson Walker plays the self-confessed douche with a swaggering flamboyancy that works well. Yes Romeo is a wet lettuce, but that’s how he’s written here, and he doesn’t take as a large role as you might expect.

A huge ensemble fill the stage with seemingly effortless energy and slick choreography throughout. They cleverly mask scene transitions and costume changes, and keep the show moving with ease. They’re all dressed in period attire but with a modern twist, and Palmona Young’s costumes are a triumph.

&Juliet is a feast for the senses, and worthy of the West End in terms of production values. Soutra Gilmour’s eclectic set transports us between London, Verona and Paris, through neon lights, giant balloons and grungy shabby-chic set pieces. At one point Juliet swings from a chandelier, rides a moon swing and is pedalled by a fairground-horse rickshaw. There’s plenty of razzle dazzle too, from pyrotechnics and smoke to raining glitter.

On a technical note, the sound levels were slightly out of balance at points. This is a shame as the vocals are so strong and well delivered, but sometimes drowned out by the music. Dialogue was occasionally a strain to hear too, even from the mid stalls. Hopefully these technical issues can be ironed out as the run goes on, and I suspect they were opening night niggles.

This eager audience were itching to get up and dance but – thankfully – posters and announcements ask to refrain from this until directed by the cast. This is a sensible touch; in Leeds many people treated it like a concert and crooned along to the 90s hit list.

When the moment does come though, there’s no stopping us. We all bopped along to Can’t Stop the Feeling, and the show received a resounding and well deserved standing ovation. A celebration of independence, of being yourself and carving your own path in life.

Family friendly? It’s certainly a fun, fast-paced and colourful show. There were several primary school groups in last night, and the age rating is 8+. However there are sexual themes, and strong language – especially in P!nk’s F**king Perfect. It’s a song title that probably sums up the show well though, and it comes highly recommended.

Not booking a ticket would be the real…tragedy!

&Juliet runs at Sheffield’s Lyceum Theatre until Saturday 31st May. Book your tickets at https://www.sheffieldtheatres.co.uk/events/and-juliet

Disclaimer: Tickets were kindly provided for this performance, however all opinions are honest and are our own.

Leave a comment